Since this review is about The Archer, The Hero, The Gunslinger, and The Shark beard oils, I gave it a five-star HANDS DOWN.
I already love The Hero(Warm Cologne)5/5, but I'm not much of a fan of The Gunslinger(Patchouli)3/5 (although it's not bad enough to be upset over or anything. I'm definitely still going to use it.)
Anyway, I would give The Archer a 4/5 personally. Those of you that really enjoy a STRONG Pine scent will absolutely love it. I still use it, but the Pine intensity is just not my thing.
The Shark however, is perfect in my opinion. The artwork on the bottle, the overall quality of the oil, the amazing scent, and OF COURSE the incredible price point, I'm not positive that I could beat this product with anything else. I will be purchasing this scent as long as they continue to produce it.
I strongly recommend The Shark scented oil.
After my purchase of these 4 bottles, I've concluded that The Shark (Deep Sea - a very light and fresh cologne) is by far my favorite 100/5. The hero coming in at a fair second place 5/5. The Archer in third 4/5, and the Gunslinger in last 3/5.