ALL-NATURAL
INGREDIENTS
MADE IN
USA
40,000+
FIVE STAR
REVIEWS
WORRY-FREE
SCENT
GUARANTEE
Pumpkin Eater - Cologne - Prize Pumpkin Pie, Creamy Whipped Topping, Toasted Pie Crust
Pumpkin Eater - Cologne - Prize Pumpkin Pie, Creamy Whipped Topping, Toasted Pie Crust
Couldn't load pickup availability
Worry Free Scent Exchange
Worry Free Scent Exchange
If the fragrance isn’t what you expected, we’ll exchange it for another—no questions asked.
Ships In 1 Business Day
Ships In 1 Business Day
Most orders are shipped directly from our warehouse within 1 business day.
During Peak Holiday Times expect fulfillment delays of an addition 1-2 business days
The Wizard’s Promise
The Wizard’s Promise
🌿 All-natural cold-pressed oils
💯 Free of damaging phthalates
🇺🇸 Made in the USA
👃🏻 Long-lasting scents (8-10 hours)
Pumpkin Eater – Cologne
Eat to Win. Claim the Prize. Leave No Crumbs.
Prize Pumpkin Pie | Creamy Whipped Topping | Toasted Pie Crust
The Pumpkin Eater Cologne is crafted for the man who never backs down from a challenge—or another slice. A legend of the CarnEvil's infamous pumpkin pie eating contest, Pumpkin Eater has devoured his way to victory and claimed the prize year after year. With an endless appetite and a determination to defend his title, every towering pie placed before him is just another chance to prove why he's the undisputed champion of the midway. Pumpkin Eater embodies competitive spirit, carnival excess, and the sweet taste of victory.
Scent Profile
🎃 Prize Pumpkin Pie – Warm spiced pumpkin baked into a rich, prize-winning pie
🍦 Creamy Whipped Topping – Fluffy whipped cream with smooth vanilla sweetness
🥧 Toasted Pie Crust – Golden baked pastry with warm, buttery depth
What's Included
1 × 80 ml Cologne Spray – A long-lasting fragrance crafted to capture the decadent spirit of the CarnEvil's prize-winning pumpkin pie champion
Why You'll Love It
Long-lasting scent designed for all-day wear
A warm, decadent fragrance with classic carnival character
Smooth fine-mist atomizer for even application
Crafted with premium fragrance oils for lasting performance
Versatile enough for everyday wear or special occasions
Leaves an unforgettable impression that lingers long after the last slice disappears
Ingredients
Denatured Alcohol – Ensures a clean, crisp application with a lightweight finish
Fragrance Oil – Skin-safe and meets all IFRA safety standards
Fable's Risk-Free Guarantee
If Pumpkin Eater doesn't become your signature scent for defending the title at the CarnEvil, we'll make it right—no questions asked.
Eat to win.
Claim the prize.
Only from Fable Beard Co. — Where Every Beard Has A Story.
Smells great. Love Fable products.
Unfortunately I didn't like this scent at all.
Pumpkin Eater cologne smells absolutely amazing. I have received a compliments on it. It's like you are wearing Halloween around. The secnt description Fable gives is spot on too. You distinctly smell the pumpkin pie, pie crust, and the whipped topping. You don't need much either. One spray is all you need. I have done two and you can smell it all day. If you like pumpkin, don't sleep on this one. Get it!
Get this! Like going into a bakery or your grandmas house on thanksgiving

Let customers speak for us
from 40404 reviews
Awesome scent one of my top 10
I love fable beard products. They make beard maintenance for me so simple. Their products soften and help bring under control me unruly hair. Thank you
Everything!! I love Fable and their products!
First time tried wizard wasn’t super impressed. Gave it some time went back gave another try. The orange bourbon leaves a satisfying scent. Highly recommend give this one a try or two.
Fable products are the best beard products I’ve used so far. Plus, the scent isn’t overpowering and lasts all day.
Balloons deodorant rocks. Put it ion in the Morning and still smell it’s greatness in the evening.
They have one of the best deodorants on the market. Every scent has one and it goes on nice and feels great.
Love this butter, the scent profile is on point. The butter works really well.
This pairs well with The UNDEAD, it definitely has a cherry charms blow pop vibe to it.
The Apple is very subtle but the sour candy is strong. Definitely a keeper.
This has been in my rotation since I got it. I’ve gotten the whole thing little by little and it was worth every penny. If you like a carnival smell, this is it.
Not crazy about the name, but aside from that this profile is incredible. I had to put it in the beard immediately after opening. Peach is hard to get right as a smell,it usually comes off smelling fake. But not this one! Amazing profile. Id seriously give this one 6 stars if I could
Amazing scent offered with purchase! Can’t even describe the scent but it smells so good; manly and sweet after absorption. Girl loves it!
Bloodbound-Has been used daily in both conditioner and oil formats. The website mentioned almond scenting which makes a lot of sense! Though everytime I smell it all I can think of is marshmallows. It’s super sweet (in a good way). I didn’t know that a scent so sweet could be so wearable on a daily basis but it is and I love it!
Patient Zero-This scent is so good that my descriptions err in comparison. Smells exactly like a sour candy or sour gummy worm. I am using the beard wash and conditioner, and will be opening the oil and balm variants soon. I’m sure they won’t disappoint. This scent alone is 5 stars and I wouldn’t hesitate to buy it again.
Here’s the tricky part: the beard butters. I bought a snippy beard butter and got the butcher for free. Now, I’ve had a snippy deodorant from a year ago that was great. That’s not how the butter smells. Not even remotely. The butter is indescribable, but some sort of artificial old gross scent. Not something I want to smell or be on my face. The butcher butter doesn’t smell like leather, either. It’s close to the smell of lightening rod, but in a sickeningly artificial way. I’m assuming the oil will be better. When I put the butcher on I felt nauseous due to the smell, it also gave me a reaction for whatever reason. This company is amazing, and very giving. But it seems like their butters might need some work!
(Sorry for the bad picture, I was too excited when it got here to get a good one!)
Smells absolutely amazing and surprisingly refined and as always with Fable unique but difficult to describe. saving to get more products in the scent as this was a really good hit.
Pumpkin Eater - Cologne - Prize Pumpkin Pie, Creamy Whipped Topping, Toasted Pie Crust
